• Appellate Jurisdiction,  Appellate Procedure,  Attorney Fees,  Costs,  Federal Courts,  Federal Procedure,  Removal

    Appeal after Remand to State Court: Was Removal Reasonable?

    The Ninth Circuit reminds us in Gardner v. MEGA Life & Health Ins. Co., case no. 06-55045 (9th Cir. Nov. 19, 2007), that even though no appeal lies from an order remanding a removed action to state court, the removing defendant may appeal an order to pay costs and fees imposed in connection with the remand under 28 U.S.C. ยง 1447(c). Here, it pays off. MEGA was ordered to pay costs and fees when the action was remanded. It claimed the only non-diverse defendant, an individual, had been fraudulently joined for the purpose of defeating diversity jurisdiction because the statute of limitations had run as to that defendant. Applying the…